TL;DR
Most founders chase growth before they've earned retention. That's paying to fill a leaky bucket. The first visit is curiosity. The second visit is when your product starts to earn it. Whether people come back unprompted tells you everything about whether the product is actually working.
1. Why growth metrics will mislead you
Most founders are obsessed with growth. More users, more signups, more traffic. I get it, growth is hard. It's very, very hard. But if you have money to spend, you can always manufacture some. Run ads. Try to go viral. What you can't manufacture is people coming back. If they return, it's because the product earned it. If they don't, nothing else matters.
Here's an opinion that might not be popular: stop measuring everything. Conversion rates, CAC, funnel drop-off, dashboards everywhere. I don't look at any of that until I know the product has earned retention. Before that, all growth metrics are vanity, and I genuinely don't care about them.
A user finds your product and tries it once. That's your distribution working, not your product. And distribution absolutely matters; you've got nothing without it. But your product only starts working when they come back a second time. And it really starts working when they come back unprompted. No notification, no reminder, no ad. Just instinct. That's when you know you've hit something real.
There's a version of this I've seen play out at every stage of building. A founder hits some early signups, the numbers look promising, and they start talking about paid acquisition. But when you ask them how many of those users came back last week, the answer gets vague. The signups showed up. The users didn't come back. And no amount of acquisition fixes that.
Performance marketing makes you lazy. Don't spend on ads too early before you know you're ready
2. How to know if you're actually there
Ignore the total number of users. Look at cohorts. Out of the hundred people who signed up this week, how many are still using the product next week? Next month? If that number falls to zero, you don't have a product yet. You have a one-time experience.
Don't run ads before you know you can retain. All you're doing is paying to fill a leaky bucket, and a leaky bucket with more water in it is still a leaky bucket. There are some products where filling the bucket is the actual strategy, where the network value justifies the early churn, but that's a different conversation for a specific type of product. In most cases, you're spending money to accelerate something that doesn't work yet.
The best founders aren't chasing growth early. They're sitting with 10, 20, 50 users and asking one question: would these people be genuinely upset if this product disappeared tomorrow? If the answer is no, you keep iterating. Retention is the clearest signal you have that you've found something people actually need, not just something they wanted to try once.
Before you chase your next thousand users, ask yourself: how many of your last hundred actually came back?
The Founder Launchpad
Due to popular demand, I'm launching The Founder Launchpad, a 6-week program for small cohorts of founders. We start May 1, Fridays 9–10:30 AM PT. The first cohort filled up fast, I have a couple of spots available if you’re interested.
3. What to track and what to ignore
Signal | What it tells you |
|---|---|
First unprompted return | Your product earned a second visit without help |
Cohort retention at 30 days | Whether value is durable or just initial curiosity |
"Would miss it" response | Whether you've built a need, not just a novelty |
Retention before paid acquisition | Whether you have something worth accelerating |
Build your retention this week
1. Pull a cohort report before anything else. Take everyone who signed up two weeks ago. How many of them opened the product again this week? That number is your honest retention signal. If it's close to zero, pause acquisition and start conversations with the people who did come back.
2. Ask the upset question directly. Email 10 active users this week. Ask them one thing: would you be genuinely upset if this product disappeared? Their answers will tell you more than any funnel metric. The ones who say yes are the users your entire product strategy should be built around.
3. Set a retention threshold before you run a single paid ad. Define what retention means for your product. For some products it's daily. For others it's weekly. Whatever it is, make that number your condition for growth spending. Don't accelerate a leaky bucket.
I've built products across B2C and B2B through multiple scaling cycles, and this pattern holds every time. The founders who grow fastest aren't the ones with the best acquisition strategy. They're the ones who built something people actually come back to, and they knew it before they spent a dollar on ads.
There are rare exceptions in B2C where you have to fill the leaky bucket and achieve critical mass before you see retention. That’s not valid for most products. Be wise.
